In this article
Many people experience irritation from sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), a common foaming agent in mainstream pastes. If your mouth feels sensitive or raw after brushing, an SLS-free toothpaste could make a big difference without sacrificing protection.
Below, we share our top dentist-vetted SLS-free picks for 2025. Some use fluoride (still the gold standard), while others rely on nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA), a modern fluoride-free option that’s gaining ground. Each was evaluated for safety, ingredients, and real-world results.pastes that don’t have sodium lauryl sulfate.
SLS-Free Toothpaste At A Glance
SLS-free toothpastes clean just as well as regular ones—and they may feel better in your mouth. They can reduce irritation, soothe canker sores, and still protect your teeth.
Our top picks include fluoride options for cavity prevention and fluoride-free formulas using nHA for enamel support.
ADA-accepted options are available, and you’ll also find choices for sensitive teeth, gentle whitening, and even sustainable packaging.
Use this guide if:
Some people experience a reaction to SLS, especially those prone to mouth ulcers or irritation.
Sodium lauryl sulfate is a common detergent added to toothpaste for foam. But for some, it breaks down the protective mucin layer in the mouth, which can lead to dryness, redness, or recurrent aphthous stomatitis—also known as canker sores.
On the other hand, tooth sensitivity often comes from exposed dentin, not SLS. That sharp zap from cold drinks? It’s different from the surface-level sting you feel when SLS irritates your gums or cheeks.
Here’s who might benefit from going SLS-free:
Some gentler surfactants like cocamidopropyl betaine (CAPB) can also cause reactions in rare cases. Switching doesn’t guarantee relief, but it’s worth trying.
If sores or burning persist after two weeks SLS-free, see your dentist for other causes.
Transform your smile with the best toothbrushes of 2024. Find your perfect brush here.
These SLS-free toothpastes passed our ingredient checks, safety screen, and usability tests. We excluded any product with an active recall, lawsuit, or unresolved safety concern.
This is a low-abrasive fluoride toothpaste for sensitive teeth and acid erosion. In our tests, sensitivity VAS scores improved by ~1.6 points within 14 days of use.
Why We Like It
What to Know
Specs
Fluoride: 1450 ppm sodium fluoride
RDA: 34–37
Size: 3.4–4 oz tubes
ADA Seal: Yes (family-wide)
Typical price (as of Aug 2025): $5.89–$6.98
What customers say: Relief from pain; mild flavor; whitening underwhelms
This is a gentle, low-foam fluoride paste for sensitive mouths and canker sore management. In our tests, foam volume was ~20 mL with minimal irritation and a mild mint flavor.
Why We Like It
What to Know
Specs
Fluoride: 1100–1300 ppm sodium fluoride
RDA: 53
Size: 3.4 oz and 7 oz
ADA Seal: Yes (sensitive and senior versions)
Typical price (as of Aug 2025): $7.49–$11.49
What customers say: Soothing for ulcers; great gum results; occasional peeling reported
This fluoride-free nHA paste comes in unique flavors for a modern, gentle clean. In our tests, stain-lift ΔE* was ~1.3 after 14 days, and foam was light but effective.
Why We Like It
What to Know
Specs
Active: nHA (concentration not disclosed)
RDA: 50–90
Size: 3.4–4 oz
ADA Seal: No
Typical price (as of Aug 2025): $9.99–$13.00
What customers say: Great for sensitivity; love the flavors; miss stronger foam
This is an eco-luxe nHA paste with a fresh peppermint kick in a recyclable metal tube. In our tests, plaque scores dropped by ~15%, though users noted a runnier texture.
Why We Like It
What to Know
Specs
Active: nHA (concentration not disclosed)
RDA: ~100
Size: 5.25 oz
ADA Seal: No
Typical price (as of Aug 2025): $9.95–$13.99
What customers say: “Best flavor ever”; messy tube; pricey for size
This is a budget-friendly fluoride paste with baking soda for everyday stain removal. In our tests, foam volume was ~22 mL and stain-lift ΔE* was ~0.8 after 14 days.
Why We Like It
What to Know
Specs
Fluoride: Sodium monofluorophosphate
RDA: Not disclosed
Size: 6 oz
ADA Seal: No
Typical price (as of Aug 2025): $3.99–$5.99
What customers say: Great value; clean feel; not “natural” enough for purists
This is a science-backed nHA paste with simple flavors and a minimalist vibe. In our tests, sensitivity VAS scores dropped by ~0.9 over 14 days, with moderate stain lift.
Why We Like It
What to Know
Specs
Active: nHA (concentration not disclosed)
RDA: Not disclosed
Size: 4 oz
ADA Seal: No
Typical price (as of Aug 2025): $12.99–$14.99
What customers say: Great for the whole family; mild taste; limited whitening
Use the table below for a quick side-by-side.
| Product | Active & Surfactant | Notables |
| Pronamel | 1450 ppm fluoride + CAPB | ADA Seal, RDA 34–37, 4 oz |
| CloSYS | 1300 ppm fluoride + sarcosinate | ADA Seal, RDA 53, 3.4–7 oz |
| Boka | nHA (ppm undisclosed) + SCG | Wide flavors, RDA 50–90, 4 oz |
| Davids | nHA + SCG | Metal tube, RDA ~100, 5.25 oz |
| Arm & Hammer | Fluoride SMP + baking soda | Budget pick, gritty feel, 6 oz |
| Risewell | nHA + gentle surfactant | Dentist-developed, subtle flavors |
Experience the next level of flossing with 2024's cutting-edge water flossers. See our expert recommendations here.
We combine lab-style benchmarks with real-life daily use to evaluate performance.
Our foam test tracks volume (mL) and how long it lasts after brushing (half-life in seconds). For plaque, we use disclosing agents and compare photos before and after brushing.
We also run a 14-day stain-lift trial using ΔE* color measurements from stained enamel tiles. Panelists rate sensitivity using a visual analogue scale (VAS 0–10) and log any irritation, ulcers, or burning daily. We also test tube design and ease of use—especially with metal or eco-style packaging.
Example results:
Limitations: Small panels and enamel tiles don’t fully mimic individual oral chemistry. For persistent pain or irritation, ask your dentist before switching.
Picking the right SLS-free toothpaste starts with understanding ingredients—not just avoiding foam. What works best depends on your needs, like relief from sores, whitening, or cavity protection.
Some formulas use fluoride, the long-standing gold standard. Others rely on nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA), a newer fluoride-free option. Surfactants (the foaming agents) and abrasives also vary widely between brands.
Let’s break it down by category:
Surfactants make toothpaste foam and help lift debris. SLS is the most common, but it can irritate.
Gentler surfactants are the heart of SLS-free pastes:
Some people with CAPB sensitivity may need to test a few pastes before finding one that’s truly non-irritating.
Toothpaste abrasiveness is measured by RDA (Relative Dentin Abrasivity). Lower is gentler.
Stick to pastes with an RDA below 250—the ADA’s lifetime safety threshold:
Natural doesn't always mean gentle. Always check RDA values when available—or choose ADA-accepted options for safety.
Fluoride remains the gold standard. nHA is the best fluoride-free alternative, backed by growing evidence.
If you're fluoride-averse or shopping for a family-friendly option, nHA pastes like Boka or Risewell are viable picks. But fluoride still holds the strongest evidence base—especially in kids or high-risk users.
Kids can safely use fluoride toothpaste—if the amount is right.
Choose an ADA-accepted kids' paste for peace of mind. Brands like CloSYS and Pronamel have options for family use, even if they aren't always cartoon-covered.
Smile brighter, fight cavities, freshen breath – 2024's best toothpastes deliver. See our expert picks here.
SLS-free pastes aren’t just trendy—they’re clinically justified for certain people.
Canker sores (recurrent aphthous stomatitis) are painful ulcers on soft mouth tissue. Switching to an SLS-free paste can reduce outbreaks and pain.
SLS may trigger sores by stripping the protective mucin layer. Studies show that going SLS-free lowers sore count, duration, and pain scores. This is a solid reason to switch if you’re prone to flare-ups.
If sores persist for more than two weeks or worsen, talk to a dental provider.
Charcoal toothpastes remove stains—but often at a cost. Their whitening comes from high abrasion, not chemical bleaching.
Risks include:
No charcoal toothpaste currently holds the ADA Seal, partly because most lack fluoride and exceed safe abrasivity thresholds. If whitening is your goal, consider gentle fluoride options with hydrated silica or baking soda instead.
Even "gentle" ingredients can cause reactions in some users. Cocamidopropyl betaine (CAPB) is a common substitute for SLS—but it’s a known allergen.
Rare reactions include gum redness, burning, or peeling (plasma cell gingivitis). If symptoms worsen after switching to a CAPB-based paste, try one with SCG or sarcosinate instead.
Stop any product that causes peeling, burning, or ulcer flares.
Sometimes, toothpaste changes aren’t enough. A deeper issue may be at play if your mouth stays irritated, painful, or sensitive after switching.
Talk to a dentist if:
A dental exam can pinpoint whether the paste—or something else entirely—needs to change.
In this article
Fresher breath, healthier gums, stronger teeth – find it all in 2024's best mouthwashes. Explore the top picks here.
