In this article
Using the right toothpaste can do more than just clean your teeth. It can strengthen your enamel and help reverse early signs of tooth decay.
If you’re deciding between fluoride and fluoride-free options, this guide will help you understand what actually works and which picks are safest.
Every time you eat or drink something acidic—like citrus, soda, or coffee—your enamel loses minerals in a process called demineralization. Over time, this weakens the structure of your teeth, increasing the risk of sensitivity and cavities.
Remineralizing toothpaste helps repair this damage. It delivers key minerals, like calcium and phosphate, directly to the enamel.
Fluoride is the most studied and widely recommended option for this purpose. It helps rebuild enamel and forms a stronger compound called fluorapatite that resists future acid damage.
Nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) is a newer, fluoride-free ingredient designed to mimic the natural mineral structure of your teeth. Studies suggest it can also promote remineralization and reduce sensitivity.
However, fluoride still holds the strongest body of long-term evidence for preventing cavities across large populations. If you’re unsure, start with fluoride unless directed otherwise by your dentist.
Transform your smile with the best toothbrushes of 2024. Find your perfect brush here.
We reviewed top formulas to find what works, what’s safe, and what suits different goals. Each toothpaste below passed safety checks, and several have been tested for effectiveness using our in-house protocols.
This option is best for stain removal with cavity protection. In our tests, we saw a ΔE color improvement of +2.1 by day 14, making it one of the strongest surface-whitening options.
Typical price (as of Sep 13, 2025): $6.00–$10.55 per tube
Best for cavity prevention in high-risk adults and teens. In our tests, users reported a 2.7-point drop in cold sensitivity (VAS) and plaque reduction of 28% by day 7.
Typical price (as of Sep 13, 2025): $8.57–$26.95
This is the best fluoride-free option with natural ingredients. In our tests, users saw a 1.8-point reduction in sensitivity (VAS) and light stain lift after two weeks.
Typical price (as of Sep 13, 2025): $15.00–$16.00
Best gentle fluoride pick for irritation-prone mouths. In our tests, it produced a foam volume of ~26 mL with minimal sting or irritation (0–1/3 comfort score).
This is the best budget fluoride option with proven results. In our testing, it showed plaque reduction of ~22% by week one.
Best for young children learning brushing habits. In our tests, kids brushed an average of 2:04 minutes using the built-in visual timer.
Use the table below for a quick side-by-side of each brand’s details.
| Brand | Active Ingredient | Abrasivity Band | Seal/Notes |
| Rembrandt | 0.243% NaF | Medium (~85) | No ADA Seal |
| Clinpro 5000 | 1.1% NaF | Not disclosed | Rx only |
| Elims | 10% nHA | Not disclosed | Fluoride-free |
| Closys | 0.24% NaF | Low | ADA Seal |
| Colgate | ~1,100 ppm NaF | Low | ADA Seal |
| Crest Kids | ~1,100 ppm NaF | Low | ADA Seal (Kids) |
Experience the next level of flossing with 2025's cutting-edge water flossers. See our expert recommendations here.
Choosing the right remineralizing toothpaste depends on your oral health needs and your comfort with ingredients like fluoride or SLS.
Here’s what to look for when comparing formulas:
If your goals conflict—say, you want whitening but also need gentle care—talk to your provider about which trade-off is more important right now.
Fluoride remains the clinical gold standard for preventing cavities. But nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) is gaining ground as a safe and effective alternative, especially for people who want to avoid fluoride.
Here’s how they compare:
However, fluoride has more large-scale, long-term data. If you’re at high risk for cavities, fluoride is still the safest bet.
Pick the active you’ll actually use twice daily. That’s more important than chasing perfection on the label.
Getting kids to brush can be tough, and knowing how much toothpaste to use is just as important as which one you choose.
Here are the current ADA and AAPD fluoride guidelines for children:
Products like Crest Kids Color Changing help encourage longer brushing by adding fun without losing fluoride protection.
If your child has ongoing cavities or white spots on their teeth, talk to your pediatric dentist about whether prescription fluoride might be needed.
Every product we recommend has been screened for FDA recalls or safety alerts in the last 24 months.
Here’s what you should know:
If you already use either of these, check your product’s lot number or contact the manufacturer for updates.
When in doubt, switch to a clear pick. Several safe fluoride and fluoride-free options are available.
Smile brighter, fight cavities, freshen breath – 2025's best toothpastes deliver. See our expert picks here.
We don’t just read ingredient labels. We test how toothpastes perform in real-world use.
Here’s how we evaluate each formula:
Remember, everyone’s mouth is different. Our results reflect small panels and short-term use—not full clinical trials.
If you have active decay, gum disease, or tooth pain that isn’t improving, check in with your dentist before switching pastes.
In this article
Fresher breath, healthier gums, stronger teeth – find it all in 2025's best mouthwashes. Explore the top picks here.
