Updated on August 1, 2023

The Best Dentists in New Castle, PA

NewMouth is reader supported. We may earn a commission if you purchase something using one of our links. Advertising Disclosure.

Why trust us?

NewMouth is committed to connecting patients to the best local healthcare providers. We reviewed 39 dentists in New Castle, PA, and chose this list based on their:

  • Qualifications and education
  • Years of experience
  • Reputation and resources
  • Past customer experiences

We used AI technology to analyze 5641 reviews from Google, Yelp, and Facebook to find patients' favorite dentists in the area. Our team then went through and hand picked our list of the best dentists in New Castle.

5 Best Dentists in New Castle, PA

215 W Elizabeth St, New Castle, PA 16105

Gary R. Snow DDS

5 out of 5 (15 reviews)

215 W Elizabeth St, New Castle, PA 16105


Dr. Gary Snow provides professional, friendly dental care in a welcoming atmosphere. Patients comment on his painless procedures, quality treatment, and ability to put them at ease. Both adults and children are well cared for at his compassionate practice.


  • Staff provide professional, friendly service
  • Procedures designed for comfort and minimal pain
  • Dental care focused on affordably meeting patient needs

2623 Wilmington Rd Suite A, New Castle, PA 16105

Refresh Dental

4.6 out of 5 (725 reviews)

2623 Wilmington Rd Suite A, New Castle, PA 16105


The dental practice is well regarded for their friendly hygienists and clean facilities, though some patients have noted issues with insurance processing, occasional rude staff, and appointments feeling rushed. Overall patient satisfaction remains high.


  • The staff, especially the hygienist Tom, are praised for their friendliness, efficiency, and excellent service during cleanings and procedures.
  • The dental center has a professional, modern atmosphere and state-of-the-art equipment.
  • The team keeps patients informed about every step of their dental care in a transparent manner.

2539 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105

Karski Dental LLC

4.8 out of 5 (12 reviews)

2539 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105


Dr. Matt Karski provides quality dental care in a comfortable setting. Patients recommend his practice for dental implants, pediatric dentistry, and attentive care during emergencies. His friendly, professional staff aims to make every visit a positive experience.


  • Dr. Karski has extensive expertise in dental implants, and thoughtfully guides patients through the process for natural-looking, functional results.
  • The dental center provides a welcoming, stress-free environment for patients of all ages, with a skilled pediatric dentist.
  • The thoughtful support staff make visits pleasant through their friendly manner and commitment to each patient’s comfort.

2015 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105

Dr. Michael C. Mccormick, DDS

4.6 out of 5 (10 reviews)

2015 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105


The smaller, one-dentist office offers a warm, personalized dental experience. The kind staff aims to ease patient anxiety with their caring manner. Patients describe friendly, knowledgeable service from the receptionist, hygienist, and Dr. McCormick. However, those with health conditions affecting attendance should note the office may have limited accommodations.


  • Caring Staff: The dentist and staff provide compassionate care in a welcoming environment.
  • Skilled Dentist: Patients benefit from the dentist’s qualifications, knowledge and gentle approach.

1440 New Butler Rd, New Castle, PA 16101

George J Mendel DMD

3.7 out of 5 (31 reviews)

1440 New Butler Rd, New Castle, PA 16101


This dental practice has garnered mixed feedback. While some patients were dissatisfied with the dated office environment and unprofessional staff, others appreciated Dr. Mendel’s efficient, affordable care. However, reports of poor follow-up care are concerning. Although the office appears worn and Dr. Mendel’s bedside manner is brusque, prices are reasonable for basic services performed competently.


  • Dr. Mendel and his friendly staff provide quality dental care and are able to accommodate emergency appointments when needed.
  • The prices at this dental center are competitive compared to other practices in the area.
  • The dentist is highly skilled at providing efficient dental procedures for patients’ basic dental needs.

Common Dental Procedures Their Costs

Dental Exams and Teeth Cleaning

Dental exams and teeth cleaning often go hand-in-hand during a dental visit. A dentist or hygienist will check on the general health of your oral cavity. This includes your teeth, gums, and tongue.

In Pennsylvania, this treatment costs between $65 and $112.

Pediatric Dentistry

Pediatric dentistry focuses on children's oral health from infancy through the teen years. Treatments aim to maintain and improve dental health through a combination of services.

These include treating any existing dental issues in children. But pediatric dentistry also emphasizes education and preventative care. Proper brushing, flossing, nutrition, and dental sealants can help prevent issues like cavities.

Establishing these good habits early on is key. The goal is to set up a comprehensive routine focused on prevention. This helps ensure a healthy smile for years to come.

Pediatric dental treatments in Pennsylvania typically cost $84, varying based on the specific service and age of the child.

Cavity Fillings

Cavity fillings are used to treat minor tooth decay. Fillings prevent bacteria, food, and other debris from entering the tooth and progressing this decay. They can also repair teeth that are broken or worn down.

Cavity filling costs in Pennsylvania range from $169 to $285, depending on the number of surfaces affected and the type of filling material used.

Root Canals

Root canals are necessary when the innermost layer of you tooth, the dental pulp, is severely damaged. This procedure involves cleaning out the infected pulp and sealing the tooth.

Costs in Pennsylvania range from $942 to $1,309.

Gingivitis Treatment

Gingivitis treatments can involve scaling and root planing. This involves scraping tartar buildup along the gums and smoothing the teeth’s surfaces.

Treatment can also involve regular dental checkups and readjusting poorly fitted dental devices like braces or dentures.

In Pennsylvania, the cost is between $302 and $230.

Periodontal Therapy

Periodontal therapy treats gum disease, from mild gingivitis to severe periodontitis. The goal is to thoroughly clean around teeth and stop disease progression. This helps maintain natural teeth and gum health.

In early stages, careful plaque and tartar removal may be enough. Advanced disease may need surgical interventions to restore bone and tissue support. Ongoing care is important to halt further gum damage.

Teeth Whitening

Teeth whitening is a kind of cosmetic treatment for discolored teeth. It involves hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide.

Wisdom Tooth Removal

Wisdom teeth removal is necessary when the wisdom tooth doesn’t have space to erupt properly. An improper eruption can lead to infection or an impacted tooth. This means the tooth grows in partially.

Fluoride Treatment

Fluoride treatments help prevent tooth decay. These treatments can be done professionally or at home. They’re also available in toothpaste, foams, gels, and mouthwashes.

A professional fluoride treatment in Pennsylvania costs between $53 and $45, depending on whether varnish is used or not.


Dental X-rays give dentists and hygienists a comprehensive look at your oral cavity’s health. They can check your teeth, roots, jaw placement, and facial bone structure. These are necessary to give you a comprehensive treatment plan.

Dental X-ray costs in Pennsylvania range from $160 to $139, based on the type and number of X-rays needed.

Sleep Apnea Treatment

Sleep apnea treatments come in different forms. Dentists can recommend weight loss, using a wedge pillow, breathing strips, or mouthguards.

PAP therapy is another common sleep apnea treatment. Some people may need surgery to treat their condition.

In Pennsylvania, the cost for sleep apnea treatments like mouthguards typically ranges between $571 and $631. This range depends on the complexity and customization of the device.

Tooth Sealants

Tooth sealants prevent food particles, bacteria, acid, and other substances from damaging the tooth and causing cavities. They’re commonly applied to permanent teeth that haven’t had cavities yet.

In Pennsylvania, the cost for tooth sealant treatments is roughly $64 per tooth, depending on the tooth's condition and the extent of preparation needed.

Fluoride's Role in Pennsylvania's Dental Health

Fluoride Statistics in Pennsylvania

Fluoride, essential for dental health, is widely used in Pennsylvania. Here's a snapshot of its impact:

  • Access to Fluoridated Water: In Pennsylvania, 55.7% of the population had access to fluoridated water in 2018. This plays a crucial role in improving dental health across the state.
    • Pennsylvania's percentage of population with access to fluoridated water has remained relatively steady over the past decade, with a slight increase from 54.3% in 2008 to 55.7% in 2018.
  • National Standing: Pennsylvania is ranked #41 out of 50 in the U.S. for fluoridated water access.
    • Pennsylvania's rank for access to fluoridated water has remained relatively consistent from 2012 to 2018, indicating that the state has not seen a significant change in its ranking.
  • Community Impact: About 5,203,809 people in Pennsylvania were served by community water systems (CWS) with fluoridated water in 2018.

The Benefit of Fluoride in Dental Care

Fluoride in drinking water helps prevent tooth decay. This can reduce the need for extensive dental work. Regular dental check-ups and fluoride treatments are important for good oral health.

Dental Schools in New Castle, PA

Local dental schools offer affordable and sliding-scale oral health services. Connect with academic clinics providing supervised, reduced-cost care to uninsured patients.

New Castle Dental

Wilmington Road/fox New Castle, PA 16105

Primary Health Network

197 East Silver Street Sharon, PA 16146

Payment Type
Payment Type

Sliding Scale

Services Offered
Services Offered

General Dentistry

New Castle Primary Care/Dental

1112 S. Mill St. New Castle, PA 16101

Services Offered
Services Offered

New Castle Dental Center offers patients access to dental hygiene, dentistry, and oral surgery services.

The Community Dental Center

38722 Saltwell Rd. Lisbon, OH 44432

Community Action Agency of Columbiana

Lisbon, OH 44432

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram